EN

ChatGPT vs Claude Make Clash Royale from Scratch

#AI Tools
2025-12-03 19:227 min read

Content Introduction
Ask Questions

In this video, the creator challenges AI models, Chat GPT and Claude, to create a game reminiscent of Clash Royale within 15 minutes, using only text-based prompts and a single canvas without any game engine or assets. The process involves providing both AIs with the same prompt derived from another AI and evaluating who performs better. While Chat GPT struggles to create a functional game, Claude successfully produces a playable 3D version with detailed gameplay mechanics in half the time. The video concludes with a comparison of their performances and hints at the potential for Claude to tackle more complex projects, like creating GTA 6 from scratch.

Key Information

  • The speaker discusses an idea to pit AI models ChatGPT and Claude against each other to create a game similar to Clash Royale in a 15-minute challenge.
  • Both AI will receive the same prompt to ensure a fair competition, with additional instructions to make the game playable using 3JS.
  • The speaker uses coding tools and expresses humor while encountering issues in game development, noting that Chad GPT was unable to create a functional 3D game.
  • In contrast, Claude successfully creates a game with impressive features in a shorter amount of time, demonstrating its effectiveness.
  • The speaker concludes that Claude clearly outperformed ChatGPT and expresses interest in challenging Claude to create a game like GTA 6 from scratch.

Timeline Analysis

Content Keywords

ChatGPT vs Claude

The video explores a challenge where ChatGPT and Claude are tasked to create a game similar to Clash Royale using only a canvas and a 15-minute timer. The outcome evaluates their performance in generating game assets and code.

AI Game Development

The narrator sets a 15-minute timer for both AIs to code a playable version of Clash Royale, comparing their abilities to write JavaScript and integrate 3D graphics. Claude appears to have a better outcome than ChatGPT.

3JS and WebGL

The challenge requires the use of 3JS graphics, which can only function through WebGL, emphasizing the technical requirements for developing web-based games.

Game Mechanics Demonstration

During the testing phase, the narrator demonstrates what the game looks like under the control of the AIs, noting areas of failure and success, particularly in user interaction and game functionality.

Creator Experience

The creator discusses the experience of collaborating with AI to build a game, highlighting both the strengths and weaknesses of each AI's design capabilities, leading to a decision to potentially task Claude with creating a game like GTA 6 next.

Related questions&answers

What is the main idea of the video?

The main idea is to see which AI, ChatGPT or Claude, can create a game like Clash Royale within a 15-minute timer.

What tools are being used for this project?

The project uses simple code and a web browser, specifically WebGL for rendering, and the videos mention using Notepad for coding.

What were the results of the AI's efforts?

Claude was able to create a functional 3D game in less time than ChatGPT, which failed to create a working game.

What happens during the game creation process?

The AIs receive prompts to create the game, and the process involves coding and then testing the output in a browser.

What are some gameplay mechanics mentioned?

The gameplay includes left-clicking to drag and rotate the camera, right-clicking to adjust height, and mouse wheel controls to zoom in and out.

What future projects are hinted at in the video?

There is a mention of potentially having Claude create GTA 6 from scratch.

How was Claude's performance compared to ChatGPT?

Claude performed better by creating a fully functional game in less time, while ChatGPT's efforts did not yield a playable game.

What does the speaker think about the AI's understanding of Clash Royale?

The speaker doubts that the AIs truly understand how Clash Royale works, especially after noting the errors in the game they created.

More video recommendations

Share to: